next up previous
Next: The night sky Up: AY3 1997 Homework Assignment Previous: Eratosthenes' measurement

The geocentric theory

(a)
Describe the geocentric theory.

The geocentric theory was the paradigm that the Earth was in the center of the universe. Around Earth, which rests in the center, revolved the heavenly bodies, the planets and the stars.

The planets were first believed to revolve around the Earth in perfect circular orbits, with uniform speed. This belief was gradually backed down from as it was discovered that this could not explain the observations made. The epicyclic theory of Ptolemy tried to explain the planetary motions with circles on circles, then the centers of the circles were displaced slightly from the Earth, etc.

(b)
The geocentric theory of astronomy survived from antiquity up to the Renaissance, making it one of the most long-lived scientific theories that has ever existed. Mention two observations that this theory had problems explaining and that ultimately led to its fall.

One can think of a number of observations, for example:

tex2html_wrap_inline200 The varying speeds with which the planets move across the sky. An even more severe problem is:

tex2html_wrap_inline200 The retrograde motion of the planets, where a planet makes a little ``loop'' on the sky during the course of a few months. This happens when Earth ``overtakes'' one of the outer planets on its way around the Sun.

tex2html_wrap_inline200 The fact that Venus and Mercury are never found far away from the Sun indicates that they are orbiting the Sun, not the Earth.

tex2html_wrap_inline200 The fact that Venus shows a full range of phases.



patrik@ucolick.org